Why does Bruno lie about knowing Shmuel?

Why does Bruno lie about knowing Shmuel?

Expert Answers Bruno’s lying to Kotler about Shmuel is motivated by fear. While Bruno’s actions are in the name of resistance, he, himself, is not a resistance fighter. He only knows what he does as a reflection of his own good nature.

What did Bruno notice about Shmuel’s appearance?

Bruno looks at Shmuel’s shriveled hands, and they remind him of a model skeleton that Herr Liszt once brought to teach anatomy. Shmuel said his hands used to look like Shmuel’s, but now everyone on his side of the fence looks like he does. Bruno is shocked to see Shmuel in his kitchen.

What are the consequences of the friendship between Bruno and Shmuel?

During their search, Bruno and Shmuel are herded into a gas chamber to their deaths. The irony is that Bruno forms a friendship to ease his loneliness. Ultimately, this friendship leads to the boys’ nonexistence.

What was Bruno uncomfortable telling Shmuel?

Shmuel’s response (or perhaps I should say his silence) is very telling: Shmuel bit his lip and said nothing. He had seen Bruno’s father on any number of occasions and couldn’t understand how such a man could have a son who was so friendly and kind. Shmuel’s lack of response makes Bruno feel very uncomfortable.

How did Shmuel get a black eye?

Even after seeing the brutal beating of Pavel by Kotler, Bruno does not (or does not want to) infer that a soldier causes Shmuel’s black eye. Shmuel says that that is what they were given to wear when they came to Out-With, and their other clothes were taken away.

Is Bruno happy to look like Shmuel?

Bruno is pleased to see that Shmuel seems happier lately, though he is still very skinny. Bruno remarks that this is the strangest friendship he has ever had, since the boys only talk, and cannot play with each other.

Who Hated Shmuel?

He explained that the soldiers hated the people on his side of the fence. He hated the soldiers as well. Bruno feared that Shmuel might also hate Father. Bruno changed the subject to tell Shmuel that he’d be leaving in two days and that the following day would be their last chance to meet.

Why is Bruno’s mother unhappy at outwith?

Bruno’s mother suddenly becomes increasingly unhappy after Lieutenant Kotler gets sent away. She was close to him, and without him she feels lonely and sad. She feels Out-With (Auschwitz) is no place to raise children and is frustrated with her powerlessness over her family’s situation.

Why does Shmuel forgive Bruno so easily?

Shmuel forgives Bruno so easily for the betrayal because he really does value the friendship. Once Bruno says, “I’ve never let a friend down like that before Shmuel, I’m ashamed of myself” (175), Shmuel smiles and forgives him. This suggests that Shmuel does not hold a grudge and that he cares about his friend.

Why can’t Bruno go on a march?

Bruno is prevented from going home because he and Shmuel get caught in a march.

Why does Bruno apologize to Shmuel?

Why does Bruno plan to apologize to Shmuel? He realizes that he hasn’t been a very good friend; Shmuel was sad, and Bruno didn’t even try to cheer him up.

What does Shmuel want to do when he grows up?

Where does Shmuel want to work when he grows up? He wants to work in a school. He wants to work in a hospital.

Why did Bruno deny that he knew Shmuel?

At a moment of weakness, Bruno denies knowing Shmuel and does not stand up for him. It is at the moment where Bruno showed compassion and care by ensuring that his friend had something to eat.

Why did Bruno distan himself from Shmuel in the boy in the Striped Pajamas?

By distancing himself from Shmuel because he is afraid of the consequences of associating with the boy, Bruno contributes to Shmuel’s punishment for a crime he did not commit: stealing food.

Why does Bruno lie to Kotler about Schmuel?

In this moment of panic and fear, he lies to Kotler about knowing Bruno. It is an instant of regret, something that he recognizes is wrong, but also something that he does do. Certainly, Bruno’s instant of fear that makes him lie is offset with his strength and heroism at the end, when Bruno needs him the most.

Why did Bruno turn his back on his friend?

Additionally, it is significant because it proves to be an epiphany for Bruno. He understands that he should never turn his back on his friend. While he did so in this instant, it is a moment that serves as a reminder to never do so again.